2-28-2024 9:36am

"Carrabba's Bids Farewell to Smithtown and Central Islip Locations"

Samantha Hespos Editor

The closure of Carrabba's Italian Grill in Smithtown and Central Islip marks the end of an era for Long Island residents, as these were the only two locations on the island. The restaurant expressed gratitude, stating, "We appreciate the community's support over the years." The sentiment reflects the acknowledgment of the patrons who made the establishments a part of their dining experience, emphasizing the significance of community backing throughout the restaurant's presence in these areas.

SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY — Carrabba's Italian Grill bids farewell to Long Island, closing its sole two locations in Smithtown and Central Islip. The departure marks the end of Carrabba's presence on the island, leaving patrons in those communities without the beloved Italian dining experience they've enjoyed.

Both Smithtown and Central Islip locations have been officially removed from Carrabba's website, signaling the conclusive end to their presence on Long Island. The removal reflects the closure of these establishments and adds a tangible confirmation to the departure of Carrabba's from these communities.

"Deciding to close a restaurant is never easy," acknowledged Elizabeth Daly, spokeswoman for Carrabba's, in a statement to Patch. She clarified that the closure of the Smithtown and Central Islip locations was a business decision and not a reflection of the management or staff. Expressing gratitude, Daly added, "We appreciate the community's support over the years," emphasizing the valued relationship with patrons throughout Carrabba's presence in these communities.

Carrabba's fans face disappointment as the nearest locations are now situated in New Jersey, other states, or upstate New York. The absence of a nearby option limits accessibility for loyal patrons seeking the distinctive flavors of Carrabba's Italian Grill.

Carrabba's Smithtown was situated at 730 Smithtown Bypass, and the Central Islip location could be found at 20 North Research Place. These specific addresses were integral parts of the communities and now stand as reminders of the once vibrant Carrabba's presence in those areas.

The now-closed Carrabba's in Smithtown and Central Islip was known for its diverse menu, featuring steaks, seafood, and delectable desserts. In addition to its regular offerings, the restaurant provided catering services, happy hour deals, and a lunch menu, creating a versatile dining experience that catered to a variety of preferences and occasions.