Nassau NY
4-02-2024 11:27pm

20-Year-Old Receives Sentence for 'Unforgivable, Pointless' Long Island Killing

In a significant development following a tragic incident on Long Island, authorities have confirmed that a 20-year-old individual, who was found guilty of the heinous crime of murder during an attempted robbery, has been met with justice. The young perpetrator has been sentenced to serve the next twenty-five years of their life behind bars. This decision marks the culmination of a thorough legal process, during which the severity and implications of the crime were meticulously examined.The conviction stems from a distressing event where a man lost his life during an attempted robbery, leaving profound grief and pain for the victim's loved ones. The sentencing reflects the gravity of the offense and seeks to uphold justice for the victim and their family, as well as the broader community affected by such senseless acts of violence.While the sentencing may bring a sense of closure to some, it also underscores the importance of addressing underlying societal issues that contribute to such tragedies. It serves as a reminder of the imperative to work collectively towards fostering safer communities and addressing the root causes of crime.This outcome also highlights the dedication and commitment of law enforcement and legal authorities in ensuring that justice prevails. Their tireless efforts in investigating, prosecuting, and ultimately securing a conviction demonstrate a steadfast commitment to upholding the rule of law and protecting the rights of individuals in society.As we reflect on this sentencing, let us not only acknowledge the accountability of the perpetrator but also reaffirm our collective responsibility to strive for a society where such acts of violence are not only condemned but prevented through comprehensive measures aimed at addressing the underlying issues that contribute to crime and fostering a culture of respect, empathy, and understanding.

On Tuesday, April 2, Kyle Colthirst, hailing from Uniondale, stood before the judgment of the court to receive his sentence of 25 years to life, as announced by the Nassau County District Attorney. This pivotal moment marked the culmination of a legal process that began with Colthirst's involvement in a tragic incident. The severity of the crime and its repercussions reverberated throughout the community, leaving an indelible impact on the victim's family and friends. As Colthirst faced the consequences of his actions, the courtroom served as a solemn arena where justice was served and accountability upheld. The sentence reflects the gravity of the offense and serves as a reminder of the enduring commitment of law enforcement and legal authorities to ensure that justice prevails in our society.

At the age of 18, on November 10, 2021, Kyle Colthirst, along with three other individuals, reportedly orchestrated a plan that led to the tragic death of 24-year-old Kyle Midtlyng. Allegedly luring Midtlyng into a perilous situation, Colthirst and his accomplices set in motion a chain of events that resulted in a loss that deeply impacted the victim's loved ones and the wider community. The details of the incident underscore the devastating consequences of reckless actions and the profound impact they can have on individuals and society as a whole.

As per the DA’s Office, one of Colthirst’s co-defendants, Tariq Pitaud, was responsible for initiating contact with Midtlyng via text message to arrange a marijuana purchase on the fateful evening. Meanwhile, the other two co-defendants, Tyrel Cason Jr. and Khamarie Elie, accompanied Colthirst as they drove to the location where the crime took place. This coordination among the individuals involved sheds light on the premeditated nature of the incident and underscores the gravity of their collective actions. Such calculated planning serves as a stark reminder of the risks associated with illegal activities and the tragic consequences that can ensue.

On that fateful night, Colthirst and his companions journeyed to 1001 Alexander Avenue in Uniondale with the intention of meeting Midtlyng. Their plan was to rob the Hempstead man, who awaited them in his car at the designated location. This deliberate choice of action underscores the calculated nature of their scheme and the callous disregard for the safety and well-being of the victim. The events that unfolded serve as a tragic reminder of the consequences of criminal behavior and the irreversible impact it can have on individuals and communities.

Upon their arrival at the scene, Colthirst entered the passenger seat of Midtlyng's vehicle as planned. Tragically, he then proceeded to shoot Midtlyng in the right side, causing severe injuries that included piercing his aorta and both lungs. Following the heinous act, Colthirst and his accomplices fled the scene, escaping down Lee Road. This harrowing sequence of events highlights the ruthlessness of the perpetrators and the devastating consequences of their actions. The gravity of the situation underscores the urgent need for justice and accountability in cases of such senseless violence.

Midtlyng's life tragically came to an end at the scene, where he was pronounced dead after being discovered by a 911 caller lying in the middle of the road. The heartbreaking discovery of his lifeless body serves as a grim reminder of the irreversible consequences of violence and the profound loss experienced by his loved ones and the community. The swift response of emergency services highlights the importance of prompt intervention in such distressing situations, yet it cannot erase the pain caused by this senseless act of aggression. As the investigation unfolded, it underscored the urgent need for justice and measures to prevent similar tragedies in the future.

According to the DA’s Office, incriminating evidence emerged linking Colthirst to the crime scene. His blood was reportedly discovered on the sidewalk of Lee Road, providing damning proof of his involvement. Additionally, electronic monitoring data from a device Colthirst was wearing placed him at the scene of the crime during the time of the incident. This convergence of evidence formed a compelling case against him. Colthirst's subsequent arrest in Suffolk County in January 2022 marked a significant step forward in the pursuit of justice for the victim and his grieving loved ones.

"Colthirst's scheme took a fatal turn when he brandished a loaded gun and opened fire," stated District Attorney Anne T. Donnelly. Her statement encapsulates the tragic escalation of events that culminated in the loss of a life and underscores the gravity of Colthirst's actions.

"Today’s sentence holds this defendant accountable for his inexcusable violence and for senselessly taking another young man’s life," emphasized District Attorney Anne T. Donnelly. Colthirst faced serious charges, including murder, attempted robbery, and criminal possession of a weapon (two counts). These charges reflect the severity of his actions and underscore the legal consequences of his involvement in the tragic incident. The sentencing serves as a crucial step towards justice and sends a clear message that such acts of violence will not be tolerated in society.

Colthirst's guilt was established on all charges during his trial in October 2023. The jury, after deliberating for just three days, rendered a unanimous verdict, affirming the prosecution's case against him. This swift and decisive outcome underscores the strength of the evidence presented and the gravity of Colthirst's actions. The verdict brings a measure of closure to the legal proceedings while highlighting the importance of holding individuals accountable for their actions in the pursuit of justice.

More News from Nassau
I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive